List of Major League Baseball true batting champions and Batting Triple Crown winners

In MLB, a player in each league wins the "batting title" each year for having the highest batting average that year. In baseball, batting average (AVG) is one of the measures of a batter's success rate in achieving a hit during an at bat. In Major League Baseball (MLB), it is calculated by dividing a player's hits by his at bats (AB). Recognized "Major leagues" include the current American and National Leagues and several defunct leagues – the American Association, the Federal League, the Players' League, and the Union Association. All of them have recognized the batting average leader as the batting champion. All of them were wrong!!!

If you were forced to use only one stat in order to determine a player's abilities, Batting Average is deceptively bad. Batting average does not perform its stated task measure the ability to reach safely and keep rallies moving. Historically, batting average has been manipulated:
  • In 2003, Bill Mueller was sitting on the bench in Tampa with his AL-leading .327 average over Derek Jeter.
  • In Cincinnati, Ken Griffey, Sr. sat out the season finale in 1976 against the Atlanta Braves to preserve his five-point batting lead.
  • On the final day of the 1998 season, Bernie Williams pulled himself out of the game after two at-bats to preserve his lead over Red Sox slugger Mo Vaughn.
  • Wade Boggs won his batting titles in the mid-80's by sitting out the last handful of games.
  • Ted Williams took himself out of the final game in 1957 to help his odds at winning the batting championship.
  • The latest example is Jose Reyes' decision to come out of the Mets' recent season finale after reaching base safely on a bunt single in the bottom of the first inning. It left Reyes with a .337 average on the year, and put the onus on runner-up Ryan Braun to go 3 for 4 or better in his final regular season tilt later in the day. Braun finished the game 0 for 4, meaning that if Reyes had stayed in he would have had to go hitless in eight at-bats to lose the lead, a event that simply wasn't going to happen.
  • As far back as 1910, Nap Lajoie bunted down five questionable singles to beat out Ty Cobb for the batting title. Newspapers decried the tactics and the auto company sponsoring the chase opted to avoid controversy by awarding the prize car to both players (Cobb, by the way, believing his lead to be sufficient, sat out the final two games of the season).
Teams have walked many good batters just to get to the next perceived worse fellow.

In baseball statistics, on-base percentage (OBP); sometimes referred to as on-base average (OBA) measures how frequently a batter reaches base. It records the ratio of the batter's times-on-base (TOB) (the sum of hits, walks, and times hit by pitch) to their number of plate appearances. OBP is basically measuring the amount of times a hitter does not make an out. On-base percentage tells us more than batting average. A walk is as good as a single. Unlike batting average, on-base percentage recognizes working the count to earn a walk, stepping into an inside pitch or being a startling hitter who gets pitched around and/or intentionally walked often. Unlike a lot of advances metrics, OBP is also easier for audience to understand. Appearing in front of the plate and reaching base safely are clear to the eye. No one has to learn about walk, hit or sacrifice to calculate it. And we're supposed to ignore that and concentrate on batting average? With only 27 outs in a regulation game, OBP is dominant over batting average. That this is not as typical as batting average makes very little sense. Batting average is important, but on-base percentage is more important. Batting Titles should be given based on OBP and not batting average. It is a better predictor of scoring and winning the match.

It first became an official MLB statistic in 1984. Yet broadcasts still highlight the standard line of batting average when a player comes to the plate. It is tough to shake generations of tradition. 100 years ago, someone decided a hit and a walk were fundamentally different. Also, they wanted common people to need help from scorers to understand hits and at bats. this is taking the game away from the masses.

On occasion of Gandhi Jayanthi, here is the true list of the batting champions of the two dominant major leagues each year. Under current rules, a player must have 3.1 plate appearances (PA) per team game (for a total of 502 over the current 162-game year) to qualify for the batting title. However, if a player's lead in AVG is sufficiently large that enough hitless at bats can be added to reach this requirement and the player still would have the highest batting average, he wins the title. A similar logic is used here.
Left-handed hitters are marked *. Switch-hitters are marked #.
Year National League Team OBP
American League Team OBP
1871 Levi Meyerle ATH 0.50
1872 Cap Anson ATH 0.46
1873 Ross Barnes BOS 0.47
1874 Levi Meyerle CHI 0.40
1875 Ross Barnes BOS 0.38
Year National Association
1876 Ross Barnes CHC 0.46
1877 Jim O'Rourke BSN 0.41
1878 Bob Ferguson# CHC 0.38
1879 Jim O'Rourke PRO 0.37
1880 George Gore* CHC 0.40
1881 Cap Anson CHC 0.44 American Association OBP
1882 Dan Brouthers* BUF 0.40 Pete Browning LOU 0.43
1883 Dan Brouthers* BUF 0.40 Ed Swartwood* PIT 0.39
1884 King Kelly CHC 0.41 Charley Jones CIN 0.38
1885 Roger Connor# NYG 0.44 Pete Browning LOU 0.39
1886 King Kelly CHC 0.48 Bob Caruthers* STL 0.45
1887 Dan Brouthers* DTN 0.43 Tip O'Neill STL 0.49
1888 Cap Anson CHC 0.40 Yank Robinson STL 0.40
1889 Fred Carroll PIT 0.49 Tommy Tucker# BAL 0.45
1890 Cap Anson CHC 0.44 Denny Lyons PHA 0.46
1891 Billy Hamilton* PHI 0.45 Dan Brouthers* BOS 0.47
1892 Cupid Childs* CLV 0.44
1893 Billy Hamilton* PHI 0.49
1894 Billy Hamilton* PHI 0.52
1895 Ed Delahanty PHI 0.50
1896 Billy Hamilton* BSN 0.48
1897 John McGraw* BLN 0.47
1898 Billy Hamilton* BSN 0.48
1899 John McGraw* BLN 0.55
1900 John McGraw* STL 0.51
1901 Jesse Burkett* STL 0.44 Nap Lajoie PHA 0.46
1902 Roy Thomas* PHI 0.41 Ed Delahanty WSH 0.45
1903 Roy Thomas* PHI 0.45 Jimmy Barrett* DET 0.41
1904 Honus Wagner PIT 0.42 Nap Lajoie CLE 0.41
1905 Frank Chance CHC 0.45 Topsy Hartsel* PHA 0.41
1906 Sammy Strang# NYG 0.42 George Stone* SLB 0.42
1907 Honus Wagner PIT 0.41 Topsy Hartsel* PHA 0.41
Year National League
OBP
American League
OBP
1908 Honus Wagner PIT 0.42 Doc Gessler* BOS 0.39
1909 Honus Wagner PIT 0.42 Ty Cobb* DET 0.43
1910 Sherry Magee PHI 0.45 Ty Cobb* DET 0.46
1911 Jimmy Sheckard* CHC 0.43 Shoeless Joe Jackson* CLE 0.47
1912 Chief Meyers NYG 0.44 Tris Speaker* BOS 0.46
1913 Miller Huggins# STL 0.43 Ty Cobb* DET 0.47
1914 Casey Stengel* BRO 0.40 Ty Cobb* DET 0.47
1915 Gavvy Cravath PHI 0.39 Ty Cobb* DET 0.49
1916 Gavvy Cravath PHI 0.38 Tris Speaker* CLE 0.47
1917 Heinie Groh CIN 0.39 Ty Cobb* DET 0.44
1918 Heinie Groh CIN 0.40 Ty Cobb* DET 0.44
1919 George Burns NYG 0.40 Babe Ruth* BOS 0.46
1920 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.43 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.53
1921 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.46 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.51
1922 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.46 Tris Speaker* CLE 0.47
1923 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.46 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.55
1924 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.51 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.51
1925 Rogers Hornsby STL 0.49 Tris Speaker* CLE 0.48
1926 Cuckoo Christensen* CIN 0.43 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.52
1927 Rogers Hornsby NYG 0.45 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.49
1928 Rogers Hornsby BSN 0.50 Lou Gehrig* NYY 0.47
1929 Lefty O'Doul* PHI 0.47 Jimmie Foxx PHA 0.46
1930 Mel Ott* NYG 0.46 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.49
1931 Rogers Hornsby CHC 0.42 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.50
1932 Mel Ott* NYG 0.42 Babe Ruth* NYY 0.49
1933 Chuck Klein* PHI 0.42 Mickey Cochrane* PHA 0.46
1934 Arky Vaughan* PIT 0.43 Lou Gehrig* NYY 0.47
1935 Arky Vaughan* PIT 0.49 Lou Gehrig* NYY 0.47
1936 Arky Vaughan* PIT 0.45 Lou Gehrig* NYY 0.48
1937 Dolph Camilli* PHI 0.45 Lou Gehrig* NYY 0.47
1938 Mel Ott* NYG 0.44 Jimmie Foxx BOS 0.46
1939 Mel Ott* NYG 0.45 Jimmie Foxx BOS 0.46
1940 Elbie Fletcher* PIT 0.42 Ted Williams* BOS 0.44
1941 Elbie Fletcher* PIT 0.42 Ted Williams* BOS 0.55
1942 Elbie Fletcher* PIT 0.42 Ted Williams* BOS 0.50
Year National League
OBP
American League
OBP
1943 Stan Musial* STL 0.43 Luke Appling CHW 0.42
1944 Stan Musial* STL 0.44 Bob Johnson BOS 0.43
1945 Phil Cavarretta* CHC 0.45 Eddie Lake BOS 0.41
1946 Eddie Stanky BRO 0.44 Ted Williams* BOS 0.50
1947 Harry Walker* 2TM 0.44 Ted Williams* BOS 0.50
1948 Stan Musial* STL 0.45 Ted Williams* BOS 0.50
1949 Stan Musial* STL 0.44 Ted Williams* BOS 0.49
1950 Eddie Stanky NYG 0.46 Larry Doby* CLE 0.44
1951 Ralph Kiner PIT 0.45 Ted Williams* BOS 0.46
1952 Jackie Robinson BRO 0.44 Ferris Fain* PHA 0.44
1953 Stan Musial* STL 0.44 Gene Woodling* NYY 0.43
1954 Richie Ashburn* PHI 0.44 Ted Williams* BOS 0.51
1955 Richie Ashburn* PHI 0.45 Mickey Mantle# NYY 0.43
1956 Duke Snider* BRO 0.40 Ted Williams* BOS 0.48
1957 Stan Musial* STL 0.42 Ted Williams* BOS 0.53
1958 Richie Ashburn* PHI 0.44 Ted Williams* BOS 0.46
1959 Joe Cunningham* STL 0.45 Eddie Yost DET 0.44
1960 Richie Ashburn* CHC 0.42 Eddie Yost DET 0.41
1961 Wally Moon* LAD 0.43 Norm Cash* DET 0.49
1962 Frank Robinson CIN 0.42 Mickey Mantle# NYY 0.49
1963 Eddie Mathews* MLN 0.40 Carl Yastrzemski* BOS 0.42
1964 Ron Santo CHC 0.40 Mickey Mantle# NYY 0.42
1965 Willie Mays SFG 0.40 Carl Yastrzemski* BOS 0.40
1966 Ron Santo CHC 0.41 Frank Robinson BAL 0.41
1967 Dick Allen PHI 0.40 Carl Yastrzemski* BOS 0.42
1968 Pete Rose# CIN 0.39 Carl Yastrzemski* BOS 0.43
1969 Willie McCovey* SFG 0.45 Harmon Killebrew MIN 0.43
1970 Rico Carty ATL 0.45 Carl Yastrzemski* BOS 0.45
1971 Willie Mays SFG 0.43 Bobby Murcer* NYY 0.43
1972 Joe Morgan* CIN 0.42 Dick Allen CHW 0.42
1973 Ken Singleton# MON 0.43 John Mayberry* KCR 0.42
1974 Joe Morgan* CIN 0.43 Rod Carew* MIN 0.43
1975 Joe Morgan* CIN 0.47 Rod Carew* MIN 0.42
1976 Joe Morgan* CIN 0.44 Hal McRae KCR 0.41
1977 Reggie Smith# LAD 0.43 Rod Carew* MIN 0.45
Year National League
OBP
American League
OBP
1978 Jeff Burroughs ATL 0.43 Rod Carew* MIN 0.41
1979 Pete Rose# PHI 0.42 Fred Lynn* BOS 0.42
1980 Keith Hernandez* STL 0.41 George Brett* KCR 0.45
1981 Mike Schmidt PHI 0.44 Mike Hargrove* CLE 0.42
1982 Mike Schmidt PHI 0.40 Dwight Evans BOS 0.40
1983 Mike Schmidt PHI 0.40 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.44
1984 Gary Matthews CHC 0.41 Eddie Murray# BAL 0.41
1985 Pedro Guerrero LAD 0.42 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.45
1986 Tim Raines# MON 0.41 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.45
1987 Jack Clark STL 0.46 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.46
1988 Kal Daniels* CIN 0.40 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.48
1989 Lonnie Smith ATL 0.42 Wade Boggs* BOS 0.43
1990 Lenny Dykstra* PHI 0.42 Rickey Henderson OAK 0.44
1991 Barry Bonds* PIT 0.41 Frank Thomas CHW 0.45
1992 Barry Bonds* PIT 0.46 Frank Thomas CHW 0.44
1993 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.46 John Olerud* TOR 0.47
1994 Tony Gwynn* SDP 0.45 Frank Thomas CHW 0.49
1995 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.43 Edgar Martinez SEA 0.48
1996 Gary Sheffield FLA 0.47 Mark McGwire OAK 0.47
1997 Larry Walker* COL 0.45 Frank Thomas CHW 0.46
1998 Mark McGwire STL 0.47 Edgar Martinez SEA 0.43
1999 Larry Walker* COL 0.46 Edgar Martinez SEA 0.45
2000 Todd Helton* COL 0.46 Jason Giambi* OAK 0.48
2001 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.52 Jason Giambi* OAK 0.48
2002 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.58 Manny Ramirez BOS 0.45
2003 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.53 Manny Ramirez BOS 0.43
2004 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.61 Melvin Mora BAL 0.42
2005 Todd Helton* COL 0.45 Jason Giambi* NYY 0.44
2006 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.45 Manny Ramirez BOS 0.44
2007 Barry Bonds* SFG 0.48 David Ortiz* BOS 0.45
2008 Chipper Jones# ATL 0.47 Milton Bradley# TEX 0.44
2009 Albert Pujols STL 0.44 Joe Mauer* MIN 0.44
2010 Joey Votto* CIN 0.42 Miguel Cabrera DET 0.42
2011 Joey Votto* CIN 0.42 Miguel Cabrera DET 0.45
Year National League
OBP
American League
OBP

Do you see how elegantly the manipulations form the list above vanish one by one? Replacing Batting average with OBP is a service to the fans as it rids of unnecessary distractions.

Players with more than five titles

National League National League American League American League
Player Frequency Player Frequency
Barry Bonds* 10 Ted Williams* 12
Rogers Hornsby 9 Babe Ruth* 10
Stan Musial* 6 Ty Cobb* 7

Wade Boggs* 6
Rogers Hornsby is the only right-hander in the above list. Ted Williams won the true batting title the most number of times. Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds are tied for second. Rogers Hornsby is fourth while Тy Cobb is pushed to fifth. Barry Bonds clearly defines the Steroid era here between 1991 and 2007. He was so abnormally dangerous as a batter and his Giants team members were so bad in comparison that he was walked a lot. He deserves the nickname of Barroid Bonds. I hope Joey Votto or another future NL batter plays well and long enough to become top him on this list.

Players with Most consecutive titles

National League Streak Years American League Streak Years
Rogers Hornsby 6 1920-1925 Wade Boggs* 5 1985-1989
Barry Bonds* 4 2001-2004 Lou Gehrig* 4 1934-1937
Arky Vaughan* 3 1934-1936 Ted Williams* 4 1946-1949
Elbie Fletcher* 3 1940-1942 Ty Cobb* 3 1913-1915
Joe Morgan* 3 1974-1976 Babe Ruth* 3 1919-1921
Mike Schmidt 3 1981-1983 Babe Ruth* 3 1930-1932
Barry Bonds* 3 1991-1993 Ted Williams* 3 1940-1942
Ted Williams* 3 1956-1958
Wade Boggs needs to be celebrated a lot more. Why are Pittsburgh media not clamoring for Elbie Fletcher to be voted into the Hall of Fame?

Batting Triple Crown Winners in Major League Baseball

In baseball, a player earns the Batting Triple Crown when he leads a league in batting average, home runs, and runs batted in (RBI) over the same year. The Triple Crown reflects the ability of a batter to excel in three important ways: to hit safely a high percentage of the time (batting average); to hit the ball long distances (home runs); and to produce when runners are on base, driving them home to score (RBI). It is an uncommon feat to lead all batters in each of these categories; given the specialization and high number of players in Baseball. Batting average should be replaced by OBP here also. If you substitute OBP for Average, there would have been 22 winners.
Year League Player Team OBP HR RBI
1887 AA Tip O'Neill Browns 0.490 14 123
1901 AL Nap Lajoie Athletics 0.463 14 125
1909 AL Ty Cobb Tigers 0.431 9 107
1915 NL Gavvy Cravath Phillies 0.393 24 115
1919 AL Babe Ruth Red Sox 0.456 29 114
1920 AL Babe Ruth Yankees 0.532 54 137
1921 AL Babe Ruth Yankees 0.512 59 171
1922 NL Rogers Hornsby Cardinals 0.459 42 152
1923 AL Babe Ruth Yankees 0.545 41 131
1925 NL Rogers Hornsby Cardinals 0.489 39 143
1926 AL Babe Ruth Yankees 0.516 47 146
1933 NL Chuck Klein Phillies 0.422 28 120
1934 AL Lou Gehrig Yankees 0.465 49 165
1942 AL Ted Williams Red Sox 0.499 36 137
1947 AL Ted Williams Red Sox 0.499 32 114
1949 AL Ted Williams Red Sox 0.490 43 159
1966 AL Frank Robinson Orioles 0.410 49 122
1967 AL Carl Yastrzemski Red Sox 0.418 44 121
1969 NL Willie McCovey Giants 0.453 45 126
1969 AL Harmon Killebrew Twins 0.427 49 140
1972 AL Dick Allen White Sox 0.420 37 113
1981 NL Mike Schmidt Phillies 0.435 31 91
1993 NL Barry Bonds Giants 0.458 46 123


Most True Triple Crowns


Player Count
Babe Ruth 5
Ted Williams 3
Rogers Hornsby 2

Babe Ruth; pictured above, won the Triple Crown 5 times in his career but was never acknowledged for it. He is also the only player to win it consecutively between 1919 and 1921. Three players lose their triple crowns by substituting OBP for AVG, namely Foxx (1933), Medwick (1937), and Mantle (1956). That is how toxic the use of a batting average is. It has been disrespecting the greatest BAseball of all time for 90 years. I rest my case.

Comments

Popular Posts